Case Studies

 

Cheung Sha Wan West, Phase-II

 

Notable Features
 
bullet Construction waste reduction/recycling program
bullet Reduced construction waste due to use of factory manufactured precast concrete elements
bullet Application of large panel steel formwork
bullet Use of drywall for the internal partitions
bullet Use of semi-precast slab
bullet Use of precast facade
bullet Use of precast staircase
bullet Use of precast cooking bench
bullet Use of prefabricated door sets
bullet Use of spray plastering
bullet Use of gondola to apply external finishes
bullet Use of steel fabric reinforcement
bullet On-site sorting of waste
bullet Reuse of steel formwork panels
bullet Reuse of surplus steel bars
bullet Reuse of steel hoarding

Basic Information
 
bullet Location: Cheung Sha Wan West
bullet Building Type: Residential 
bullet Contract Period: 2 years
bullet Scheduled Completion: Nov 2000
bullet Client: The Hong Kong Housing Authority
bullet Architect: Ho & Partners Architects, Engineers & Development Consultants Ltd.
bullet Structural Engineer: Mitchell, McFarlane, Brentnell & Partners International Ltd.
bullet E&M Consultant: Twin Way Consulting Engineers Ltd.
bullet Quantity Surveyor: C. S. Toh & Sons & Associates
bullet Main Contractor: Yau Lee Construction Co., Ltd.
bullet Contract Sum: HK$ 750 million

Overview
 
The Cheung Sha Wan West Phase-II was a residential building project and the following major items were executed under this contract:
 
bullet 1 no. 41 storey Harmony 1 (Option10), approximately 48 x 53 m overall on plan and approximately 113 m high from ground floor to main roof level. The long wing of each block is linked to its short wing with a 90o angle link core approximately 17 x 17 m overall on plan. The block contains 79 no. Type 1P, 240 no. Type 1B, 320 no. Type 2B, 80 no. Type 3B rental domestic units in 40 domestic upper floors.
bullet 2 no. 41 storey Harmony 1 (Option 10) Blocks in Handed Version, each block approximately 48 x 53 m overall on plan and approximately 113 m high from ground floor to main roof level. The long wing of each block is linked to its short wings with a 90o angle link core approximately 17 x 17 m overall on plan. The blocks contain 158 no. Type 1P, 480 no. Type 1B, 640 no. Type 2B, 160 no. Type 3B rental domestic units in 40 domestic upper floors.
bullet 1 no. 21 storey new Harmony Annex 3 (Option 1), approximately 11 x 22 m overall on plan and approximately 59m high ground floor to main roof level. The block contains 140 no. Type 1P rental domestic units in 20 domestic upper floors.
bullet 2 no. 21 storey new Harmony Annex 4, approximately 21 x 17 m overall on plan and approximately 59 m high ground floor to main roof level. The blocks contain 320 no. Type 1P rental domestic units in 20 domestic upper floors.
bullet All associated drainage and external works, including lorry parking areas, roads emergency and service access, play areas, ball courts, covered walkways, refuse collection point, junk collection point, pavilion and landscape planters.
   
 

  Plastering and Finishing
   
 
Since the precast wall and floor slabs, as well as the factory made internal walls provided very smooth and accurate surfaces, thick plaster was not necessary. Plaster dropping on floor during the finishing process, sometimes accumulate to a thickness of 30mm over the whole floor area, can hardly be avoided in traditional cement sand plaster.
 

 

However, with spray plastering the same was not happened in this project. It also has the advantage of higher productivity and lower demand of labour.

   
 
   
  Gondola was used to apply external finishes. This saved the waste of bamboo scaffolding.
   
 

  Waste Management
   
  bullet On-site sorting of waste
   
  On-site sorting was partially performed. Distributed Separation was adopted. The following materials were sorted out:
   
 

bullet

Surplus reinforcement – transported to the ground level by hoist or tower crane

bullet

Packaging material – transported by hoist

bullet

Rubble + foam + plastic conduit – transported by refuse chute
   
  It had been considered that the rubble/aggregate could be as hardcore (size<200mm) for backfilling or sub-base for road. However, there was no storage space for the rubble/recycled aggregate.
   
  bullet Material Control
   
 

bullet

The sub-contractors were required to supply labourers as well as materials such that they would reduce wastage of raw materials as much as they could.

bullet

Where the main contractor supplied raw materials, sample floor/flat was used to estimate the materials required, thus ensuring the control of materials.
   
  bullet  Use of recycled materials
   
 

bullet

The steel formwork had been used for another site already. It would be reused or scrapped and transported to China for resale depending on the condition of the material.
   
  bullet

Reusable materials

   
 

bullet

surplus steel bars were stored for reuse

bullet

steel hoarding

bullet

steel formwork

bullet

steel protective canopy of standard size at 1/F – it was first used for this contract

   
  bullet

Steel fabric reinforcement was used to reduce the waste

 

   
Wall System
 
Large panel formwork was used to construct load-bearing walls of standard domestic floors. Since all the wall formwork less than 7.5m long was required to be cast in one piece, it minimised the number of joints between formwork panels; therefore, less chance of grout leakage or uneven surface finishes at joint which are usually a norm for traditional timber formwork. For durability and ease of maintenance of steel formwork, one set of formwork can repetitively be used throughout the block. For instance, one set of wallform was cyclically employed for the construction of Harmony 1 housing block with four wings. At the beginning, an 8-day floor cycle was adopted. As they had got used to the technology, a 6-day floor cycle was adopted. 
 
 
It was anticipated that the cost of steel formwork would be more or less the same when compared with timber formwork for this project. The cost of steel formwork was even cheaper when the cost of carpenter was increased to HK$3,000 per manday in the past.
 

Dry Wall
 
The internal partitions were built of factory made lightweight concrete panels. Joints were minimized by the use of large size floor-to-ceiling panels. Cutting was not necessary because the size of the panels was tailored to suit the building, thus the amount of waste that would be produced during construction was further minimized. The time required was also less than the traditional brick or block construction. 

 

 
The factory made panel gives very smooth and accurate surface finish. However, it might not be acceptable because of its lower strength in supporting point load and resistance to impact.
 

Slab System
 
Semi-precast slab was adopted to be the slab of each floor. 75mm thick precast slab was installed first at the floor level which served as the formwork for the 95mm thick in-situ concrete layer, thus forming a 170mm thick concrete floor. This saved the time in erecting and striking the timber formwork as well as forming a smooth ceiling finishes for the floor below. 
 

The cost of the semi-precast slab is now competitive to the cost of timber formwork. However, the precast slab must be handled and transported with care to prevent cracking of the slab.

 

Precast Facade
 
The precast facade was manufactured in China and transported to the site for fixing. It was stored on the ground level and was hanged to the required floor by tower crane. The precast facade with projecting angle supports at both ends was placed in position on top of the structural wall. Inclined bracing fixed onto floor slab was installed to control the vertical alignment of the facade. Construction for wall followed. Then precast slab panels were installed with scaffolding supports. The top edge of the precast facade was right at the top level of the floor slab, such that the precast facade formed the stop end for the floor slab.
 

 
It is cost effective to use precast facade in mass production.

Precast Staircase
 
The precast staircase was constructed in 8 risers. According to the building layout, the staircase was enclosed by structural walls on two sides. The mid-landing was casted as in-situ with wall supports on both ends. Due to the smooth surface quality, no applied finishes would be necessary. A metal nosing strip was the only thing that was required to finish the stair. Naturally, construction waste was not arised.
 

 

Precast Cooking Bench
 
Cooking benches were also prefabricated elements. Bench top was cladded with 1 piece 0.8mm satin finish stainless steel sheet. The bench itself was of lightweight concrete and supported by 60mm concrete support, smooth finish and epoxy painted. 
 
 
The stainless steel sink was cast in lightweight concrete bed, 75mm thick, to afford strength to stand chopping and cutting. Earthing lugs were designed and built for both sink and bench.
 

Prefabricated Doorsets
 
Prefabricated door frames and doors were used in this project. These doorsets saved temporary timber support for door frame, thus reducing waste.
 

Contact of Contractor
 
Yau Lee Construction Co., Ltd.
10/F., Tower I, Enterprise Square, 9 Sheung Yuet Road, Kowloon Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong
Tel: (852) 2753 4388
Fax: (852) 2753 4300
E-mail: info@yaulee.com

 

Low-Waste Buildings Technologies & Practices
Home